If you buy in bulk, remember that no-bake cookies stay fresh for about a week at room temperature, but you can extend their life to two weeks by keeping them in the refrigerator.

For the closest thing to "homemade," online marketplaces are your best bet.

While no-bake cookies—also known as Preacher Cookies or Haystacks —are a staple of home kitchens, finding them on store shelves can be a bit of a treasure hunt. 1. Online Marketplaces (Etsy & Amazon)

Because no-bakes don't require oven space, some local bakeries keep them as a consistent "grab-and-go" item near the register.