A major point of contention in reviews from TV Fanatic was Andy Herrera’s decision-making. She makes a split-second, irrational choice to dive into the pipes alone, nearly costing both her and the boy their lives. This moment highlights her struggle with authority and proves her father's point that she may not be ready for the captaincy. 3. Trauma and Resilience
The arrival of Captain Sullivan creates instant friction. Unlike the previous "family" atmosphere, Sullivan skips team meals and conducts rigid uniform checks. Critics from IMDb noted that while the new leadership was a good narrative move, the team's behavior—including Andy mumbling insults in Spanish—felt unprofessional. 2. Andy’s Impulsivity "Station 19" Under the Surface(2018)
: The episode resolves the cliffhanger from Grey’s Anatomy where Max ran away from the hospital. A major point of contention in reviews from