The Drifters , fronted by the soulful Ben E. King , first recorded the track in December 1959. Released in 1960, it reached #16 on the Billboard Hot 100, characterized by its "softer ballad" feel and romantic, yearning vocals.

The Story Behind the Song: This Magic Moment Whether you know it from the golden age of doo-wop or a nostalgic movie scene, "" is one of those rare tracks that feels timeless. Since its debut in the late 1950s, it has evolved from a smooth R&B ballad into a cross-generational anthem of romance. The Birth of a Classic

Jay and the Americans took the song to even greater heights nearly a decade later. Their 1968 version—featuring a faster tempo and a more dramatic arrangement—hit #6 on the charts in 1969 and earned gold record status. What Makes it Magic?